First debate of the primary on the left : we have noted the … – The Parisian

Which, of socialist Benoît Hamon, Arnaud Montebourg, Vincent Peillon, and Manuel Valls, the radical left Sylvia Pinel or environmentalist Jean-Luc Bennahmias and François de Rugy has won the debate ? The journalists of the Parisien noted.

Le jury of the Parisian deliberate. The journalists from the political department noted on Thursday evening the delivery of each of the candidates of the first debate of the primary to the left according to the five criteria. The precision, the style, fair-play, the best formula and combativeness. Each journalist has proposed a note on ten points. The one that we offer is therefore the result of an average.

Arnaud Montebourg : experienced

Threatened on its left flank by Hamon, the former minister of productive Recovery has ably addressed from the outset in the France of the forgotten. The “workers of Florange” — his fight the most symbolic, of the precarious and cashiers, for which he wants to lower the CSG to make a ” thirteenth month “. Remains to be seen whether this France of decommissioned will vote on the 22 and 29 January… Established in the year, the third man in the primary in 2011 has shown that it has, as he says, ” the experience of the State “.

Jean-Luc Bennahmias : offset

It is without doubt the least known of the candidates and the debate was important, therefore, for Jean-Luc Bennahmias. Only one to go without a tie, yesterday, the president of the small Front democratic party wanted to appear casual (a little too much perhaps). Placing his candidacy under the banner of the general interest, it has defended its proposals (the universal income, creating medical clinics to reduce congestion in the emergency room…) But if it appeared friendly, it lacked credibility and seemed to be shifted in this competition.

François de Rugy : measured

he was not the only one to torpedo the idea of a universal income proposed by Hamon, the deputy of the Loire-Atlantic is without doubt the one who found the formula to be the more biting : “This is not a basic income for balance of any account (editor’s NOTE : the fight against unemployment) “, a-t-it down. For the rest, he struggled to distinguish, as much as ecology — a central theme of his campaign — was barely mentioned in passing yesterday evening. Weighted, measured, in particular when it was necessary to evoke the balance sheet of François Hollande. At the risk of sounding bland.

Benoît Hamon : pugnacious

a Tense in the beginning of the show, Benoît Hamon has found their marks as soon as its flagship project, the universal income, was discussed. Its competitors have had good express their skepticism, the topic has become long minutes. Pugnacious, Hamon has returned in its strings Manuel Valls, who does not want a ” society of idleness and welfare “. “When Rocard had put in place the RMI, we heard the same arguments “, a down the one that meant ” to speak well of the society as it is, not as it has been.”

Vincent Peillon : faculty

Right like an I, Peillon became rigid, same faculty, sanding sometimes the rosary of its proposals. Pointing to the journalists, he vowed his willingness to turn the page of divisions “. This has not prevented it from taking its distances with Holland, which it has been concluded that the balance sheet was stained of a” misunderstanding “. “The left can govern seriously “, he launched. To better federate, it is, therefore, against the FN, and especially against Fillon, he took his best arrows.

Manuel Valls : solid

Often during the debate Thursday night, Manuel Valls has pinched lips. Especially when its competitors have scratched the record of the government. His ” pride “. He sometimes smiled, too, when such a candidate was scolded or another got lost in the convolutions. “Here, I have no opponent, even less enemy,” he insisted. The ex-Prime minister appeared on the defensive. But as precise and solid. Or how to assume, and ensure, but without the shine.

Sylvia Pinel : transparent

the Only woman in the fray, Sylvia Pinel assumes his ” candidature unique “, “the policy is not limited to men !” insists she be when she has chosen to blend in with the mass : jacket in navy blue, as these gentlemen. The president of the radical Party of the left, who is also vice-president of the region of Occitania, insists that ” rural areas are not forgotten “. And pleads for the defence of the undertakings. But lack of insurance and advance few concrete proposals.