XG For / Against – Note testing – Xbox-Gamer

News & gt; XG For / Against – Note testing

– Published on 30/11/2014 at 0:22
– By Vincent P.

Initiated for twelve Xbox Gamer, heading for the fortnightly / Counter is back this Sunday. As a reminder, the principle is simple, we are on the mat a specific topic, we explain what it is in a few lines and we try to define the least subjectively possible every positive and negative elements associated with it. For this third issue, we propose to talk about the note that accompanies the critics of video games, it is often at the root of heated debate. Its legitimacy has often been questioned, but some can not without, it also remains a weighty commercial argument for publishers … In short, it’s time to make a point! Of course, you will find below for thought and we are waiting for you in the comments to support the debate to which we will actively participate!

note, what is it? The question seems silly, everyone knowing what a note, but it is good to clarify that it is primarily a brief mention of accompanying critical highlighting the positive and negative elements of critical game. It may take the form of a numerical rating on a base 5, 10, 20 or 100, or a pictorial notation (number of stars, inches, square, etc.). It thus reflects the estimated quality of the game and / or the interest that can be said as, according to the editorial line of the site. To against   It provides visibility in the press reviews This is an easily identifiable item The publishers are still attached quite there, as many readers It helps push at the click when the note is mentioned on the site off the page of the Review C is the element that generates the most responses on the site having given or other   This is subject to some subjectivity This is a cleaving element, even when the players share the same opinion that the tester That does not mean much out of context (note she represents the interest in the game or the balance between the positive and negative aspects – with or without weighting – What really taken into account elements) It is difficult? determine the accuracy of the note (/ 5, / 10, / 20, / 100 …) It attracts more attention than the full review which is sometimes / often unread Many editors are asking the question of the legitimacy of the note, as it can be misinterpreted and / or cause strong reactions from readers who do not sometimes take the time to read the review published detailed support which helps to explain the choice of notation with respect to elements identified. Failing to present reasons for their disagreement with the tester and share their views, readers concerned only stop on the note, sometimes up to criticize openly and more or less strongly the tester. Some editors have chosen to do without but many are still attached to the legacy of the past, not to mention the fact that publishers continue to show interest, as many readers. As for Xbox Gamer, the system is at present kept even if we regularly forgive the subject up in-house … until it evolves?

YOUR REACTIONS