Rate Players is a delicate exercise that Team has long refused to practice. If notes existed since 1958 in France Football , they have appeared in our daily Thursday, November 20, 1980, the day after a heavy defeat (1-4) of the France team against West Germany. They appeared in the league seven years later, in the summer of 1987.
The system notes
Who note and how?
Those are the special envoys of our newspaper that evaluate players, even if the notes are sometimes modified seat. It happened in 1994 with the Russian Oleg Salenko, one of eight 10 of history, which was awarded a 6 by the reporter for his fivefold against Cameroon in the World. If it happens that a journalist should be alone on a match, the note is in general an average of those given by various attendees.
The reaction of players
“Sometimes a coach has to deal with problems related to the notes attributed by the newspaper” explained Christian Gourcuff in L’Equipe Mag the April 11, 2009. The players insist they never read the notes but it is often the first thing they see. Often they – or their surroundings (agent, friend or family member) – contacting journalists to inform them of their discontent. While in Hopes, Reynald Pedros had told a reporter that he was to have had a scandalous 4. Raymond Domenech, the coach intervened: “I saw the game. Frankly, I wonder where you found them, his four points … “ In 1990, Emmanuel Petit, then in Monaco, had torn the notebook of a journalist who also awarded it 4 after a Cup match Europe in Valladolid. “Because that’s how it is over, we speak no longer” , had struck the future world champion
Italy. Mirko Graziano La Gazzetta dello Sport
The system notes
“The players are rated from 1 to 10. If performance is really not good, we put a 4. We never go below, except if something serious happens. In these extremely rare cases, you can put a 3. Conversely, it does not, in general, no more than 8. In the story Gazzetta , there has been very, little 10. One of the newest is in 2010 to Diego Milito, who scored twice on 22 May in Madrid against Bayern Munich to allow his club, Inter Milan, winning the League Champions (2-0). This note had an outstanding season greeting (he also scored the goal of the victory in the final of the Italian Cup and the title in Serie A) . All Italian sports newspapers rate the players. Il Corriere della Sera does the same for politicians! “
Diego Milito has made one of the best games of his career final of the Champions League against Bayern. (Rondeau) (Team)
Who note and how?
“These are the special envoys in the stadiums, which rate the players. For evening matches, sometimes a special envoy takes care of the meeting itself, and another distributes notes, story papers be made in time for the closure. “
The reaction of players
“What’s funny is that the active players say they do not watch the notes. But once they have retired, those same players tell you that this is the first thing they looked! They attach great importance, especially as our newspaper is read throughout Europe and the world. Sometimes they make us know, through their representatives, they do not agree with the note that was given to them “
Spain. Sergi Solé, Mundo Deportivo
The system notes
Lionel Messi was carried in triumph by his teammates when he broke the scoring record in La Liga. (L’Equipe)
Who note and how?
“With few exceptions, when a journalist is still in the drafting to rate the players watching television while another is at the stage for write, one that establishes the notes is the one who writes the analysis of the game. So a lot of work. “
The reaction of players
” The first thing players look, these are the notes. But it is above them who is ahead of them before they report that they have been good or bad. The players are very sensitive to the notes. One day, a sacred Spanish international 2010 world champion said: ” You, I will talk to you more. You think I deserved fourth in the last game? But you know nothing about football ‘”
Germany: Hardy Hasselbruch, Kicker
The system notes
The Japanese Hajime Hosogai (Hertha Berlin) has taken a 6 for his performance against Hoffenheim. (L’Equipe)
Who note and how?
“It is the journalists who are in stadiums that rate the players. Sometimes two or three journalists following a club talking to each other and decide the note. We try to be as objective as possible in the notes, even if one is friends with the player. “
The reaction of players
” Players always say they do not read newspapers but I know they throw themselves on the notes. They discuss many of them. They often call journalists to shout at them and tell them they are not happy but we are used. The Germans contesting all the time the notes; they are not happy, they do not want to talk to us but it always manages. Players who have a lot of experience as Bastian Schweinsteiger really do not care. When it started, it was something else. He groaned. Franck Ribéry is not happy when he takes a 5 for sure. But that rarely happens to him. It’s normal that players are judged, it’s part of their job “
England. David Hytner, The Guardian
The note system
“From 1 to 10, and it is a tradition for decades in England. All the tabloids do. The Guardian is the only one who stopped there two years except for matches in the selection, great derbies, European finals … We have tried to note our readers on the internet but this was abandoned because it was biased. “
Who note and how?
” The journalist who wrote the analysis of the match the players noted. But it was too much work and we preferred to stop to focus on writing and because people do not need journalists to find out who was right or wrong. “
The reaction of players
” Journalists Sun or Mirror , which record players, often have problems in the mixed zone … “
No comments:
Post a Comment